This is a friendly discussion among brothers and sisters who are interested in the Book of Mormon. We look at what critics have said because most of them are sincere people who have relied on interpretations of facts and logic that we think are errors.
Brant Gardner has been writing about Heartland vs Mesoamerica on the Interpreter. But Brant also manages the conversation for the Interpreter so he limits what people can say there.
And the Interpreter refuses to provide its readers any fair, accurate comparisons of the different models.
Consequently, peer reviews of Brant's articles are on a separate blog, here: